US Supreme Court Questions Women Access to Abortion Information

Blayne Wittig executive director of Options for Women of California left a center in Concord California Debbie Whittaker nurse manager center and Christine Vatuone president and CEO of Informed Choices talk Feb. 8 at Informed Choices a crisis

Their petition supports NIFLA's side of the story that California's FACT Act violates the First-Amendment right to free speech.

On the conservative side of the bench, Justice Neil Gorsuch, hearing his first abortion-related case since taking the high court, wondered if the state could find different way to advertise its low-priced services without impinging on the speech of anti-abortion rights clinics.

"What [this law] does not do is regulate how NIFLA and other centers counsel the women who come to them", Gorod continued. Even Justice Sonia Sotomayor, one of the court's most liberal members, called one potential application of the law "burdensome and wrong".

Justice Samuel Alito seemed to agree and pointed out that the California law exempts many clinics that offer abortion.

Yet the state has done just that in two ways. Justice Elena Kagan asked if it might have been rigged in a way that would have targeted pro-life groups.

"If it has been gerrymandered, that's a serious issue", said Kagan. They want to say, constitutionally, 'We're just another wing of a political movement.

So based on Tuesday's oral arguments, California's law is nearly certainly going down.

The broader question, of whether the Supreme Court will offer sweeping protection to anti-abortion speakers - and far weaker protections to pro-abortion speakers - could remain unresolved until a future case.

The Justice Department, intervening in the case, opposed the first requirement but not the second. The court has already heard challenges from a Colorado baker who refused to make a cake celebrating a same-sex marriage and a Minnesota man blocked from wearing a tea party shirt to his polling place.

The outcome also could affect laws in other states that seek to regulate doctors' speech. California says the law is needed to let poor women know all their options.

'Reasonable licensing' or government interference?

The case revolves around a California law, AB 775, that requires pro-life pregnancy centers to tell women how they can obtain an abortion from the state.

Chiu was present on Tuesday, speaking at a counter-rally hosted by abortion group NARAL and Lady Parts Justice League, which was itself founded by former comedienne Lizz Winstead and has spent the past year harassing pregnancy help centers.

San Francisco, Oakland, Santa Clara County and Los Angeles with friends in NY and Baltimore submitted friend-of-the-court briefs supporting the law, Bay City News reports.

Britain, EU agree Brexit transition deal
Today's draft agreement on transitional arrangements is supposed to give businesses some degree of short-term reassurance. That means solving outstanding issues, notably how to avoid a "hard border" that could disrupt peace in Northern Ireland .

FA Cup Semi-Final draw: Spurs draw Manchester United
Pedro, who replaced Willian at the beginning of extra time, completed a 2-1 victory for Chelsea with his goal in the 105th minute. Mahrez put in a low cross and although Vicente Iborra was twice denied by blocks, Vardy clipped home the loose ball.

Xi Jinping unanimously elected for second term as China's president
Until last year, the 69-year-old Wang had been in charge of the Communist Party's Central Commission for Discipline Inspection. Many media surmised that China would soon return to the era of a Mao Zedong-like dictatorship .

The clinics, represented by the conservative Alliance Defending Freedom, say the court used too lax a standard when reviewing the law. He could have argued that abortion clinics - or, for that matter, regular medical facilities - do not have crisis pregnancy centers' record of seeking to mislead patients, and therefore California was justified in enacting a narrowly tailored statute meant to combat these deceptive practices where they exist.

Low-income women in particular are the most common visitors to nonprofit facilities like the ones challenging the law, but the state's publicity campaigns often miss this audience.

"I went into the pregnancy center because I was trying to hide what I was doing", she said after addressing crowd of around one hundred pro-life demonstrators.

"The state then provided exemptions for all other medical providers who serve pregnant women", he said. Violators are liable for a civil penalty of up to $500.

Critics say the centers use deceptive tactics to trick women into thinking they are entering an abortion clinic - in a bid to dissuade them from going through with the procedure.

"The First Amendment does not permit California to manipulate the marketplace of ideas in this way", it adds.

Accordingly, the California law forces the centers to do much more than promote the availability of state-subsidized abortions. A few moments later, Farris said that unlicensed clinics should not be subject to any disclosure provision because they don't provide medical procedures.

The Trump administration has taken a middle ground in the case.

Wilkinson also noted, however, that while California's law applies to both licensed and unlicensed clinics, the Baltimore rule only applied to unlicensed, religiously-associated clinics.

The notice, which the law specifies must either be posted as a public notice in "22-point type", "distributed to all clients in no less than 14-point font" or distributed digitally "at the time of check-in or arrival", applies to all pregnancy help medical clinics licensed by the state.

The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates is grateful that the Supreme Court is stepping in where California Gov.

"Informed consent is always triggered by a medical intervention", said Denise Harle, ADF legal counsel. Many of them began in church basements, but soon opened in storefronts resembling abortion clinics, sometimes near or even directly next to the clinics themselves.

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Small City Moves To Opt Out Of California Sanctuary Law
Though California is deep blue overall, there remain many pockets that support Trump and his hard-line stance on illegal immigration.

Children with Down's Syndrome take part in special Carpool Karaoke
Since it was uploaded on Friday, the video has had over one million views on Facebook and close to half a million on YouTube.

Dapchi Abduction: Nigerian Army Describes Amnesty's Claims As 'Outright Falsehood'
Amnesty equally alleged that a police source disclosed that officers fled the town over the fear that Boko Haram may "overpower them".

This mall chain is the latest to file for bankruptcy protection
The company accrued the almost $2 billion debt after Apollo Global Management LLC purchased it for $3.1 billion in 2007. The company comprises 7,500 stores, concession locations, and franchise stores under the Claire's and Icing brands.

One person dead after California mall shooting
Authorities have released the names of the woman and the ex-husband who shot her to death at a busy Southern California mall. The shooting prompted shoppers to scurry into stores and out exit doors and an hour-long lockdown.

Officials Wanted Parkland Shooting Suspect 'Forcibly Committed' In 2016
The sheriff's deputy at the school, Scot Peterson , told a clinician that he wanted to initiate a Baker Act request against Mr. The FBI is taking the blame for not acting on the situation regarding Nikolas Cruz .

'Panther' bests all rivals at box office - again
People love the original PACIFIC RIM , and the sequel promises more of what people love; giant monsters fighting giant robots. In the money: Child actor Seth Carr was paid $1,000 a day for his role as the young Killmonger in Marvel's Black Panther .

Bansky's latest NYC mural protests artist's imprisonment
She shared her picture on social media, for which she was then arrested and sentenced to almost three years in prison. Bansky told the New York Times of the piece in a statement of his motivation for the work: "I really feel for her".

Snow and ice cause weather warnings and closures for Andover
The Department of Housing, Planning and Local Government said all relevant agencies had severe weather emergency plans in place. Met Office meteorologist Mark Wilson said: "The best way to describe this is as a real return to wintry conditions".

March Madness Predictions: Will Seton Hall upset Kansas? 3/17/18
As of Saturday morning, the Jayhawks are getting 74 percent of the wagers on this game as the favorite against Seton Hall . Carrington, meanwhile, finished with 28 points, including 13 straight Pirates points in the final 1:06 the game.

Rohit Sharma didn't watch Karthik's last-ball six, here's why
Bangladesh earlier posted 166 runs for the loss of eight wickets and India came down to reach 168 runs by losing six wickets . Tamim Iqbal at the top was crucial against Sri Lanka, and will be so against India as well, especially if Das falters.

UMBC etches name in sports lore, routs top seed Virginia
Going into Friday night's game in Charlotte, No. 16 seeds in the men's tournament had been 0-135 all time . Virginia was the number one overall seed in the NCAA tournament .

FA Cup taking on added importance for United, Chelsea, Spurs
We know they were more used to the bigger stages, they don't need the ball as much'. We are in the semi-final because we deserve it.

Florida bounces St. Bonaventure after their first NCAA win in 48 years
Devin Wilson shot the last shot of the season, rolling around the rim before Tyrie Jackson tipped it in as the buzzer sounded. And they're just one really good team and Collin does a great job being aggressive and getting his teammates involved.

Six Nations 2018: Schmidt hails Irish 'class and courage' after Grand Slam
The second half was an vast power struggle, as England tried and tried and tried again to get an advantage over the Irish squad. Joey Carbery's conversion - on for Sexton while the Ireland starter was undergoing a HIA - left the half-time score at 21-5.

Other news